The Artisan Insider
  • Home
  • Small Biz
  • Artisan Stories
  • Scent
    • Perfume
    • Olfaction
  • Personal
    • Personal Updates
    • In My Garden
    • Favorites
    • Sonoma Finds: Art, Garden, & More
    • DIY
    • SSS Updates Archive
  • Blog News
  • About

The Artisan Insider

celebrating and supporting artisan businesses

  • Home
  • Small Biz
  • Artisan Stories
  • Scent
    • Perfume
    • Olfaction
  • Personal
    • Personal Updates
    • In My Garden
    • Favorites
    • Sonoma Finds: Art, Garden, & More
    • DIY
    • SSS Updates Archive
  • Blog News
  • About
Perfume

Brave New World: ingredients synthesized by micro-organisms

written by Laurie October 29, 2013

Several articles have been published recently about a relatively new technology for creating perfumery ingredients (as well as flavorings and some drugs); yeast, fungi, and bacteria can be genetically altered so that they synthesize perfumery ingredients such as vanillin. Although the yeast is a GMO substance, the ingredient it synthesizes is not GMO and is currently considered to be “natural” in the USA and Europe, though there are some challenges to that claim and we’ll have to see what happens.

One stated advantage to this new technology is potentially lower costs for ingredients and therefore the possibility for better formulas to reach the mass market by making natural ingredients more affordable. Another possible advantage would be saving natural resources like sandalwood by synthesizing them instead of harvesting them from nature. Disadvantages include putting some farmers out of business since it would be difficult to compete with the lower prices offered by biotech ingredients. You also have to wonder whether it is wise to create more GMO organisms given the problems we’ve encountered in the past with them, though these micro-organisms would be used in the lab and not introduced into the world the way GMO crops have been. This is likely to be a thorny hot topic in the future.

For more information, see the NYT article “What’s That Smell? Exotic Scents Made From Re-Engineered Yeast” and also see the article titled “Biotechnology Ushers in a New Era of Innovation for Perfumers and Flavorists” by Carolyn Fritz in the November 2013 issue of Perfumer & Flavorist. The NYT article explains the overall topic in lay terms, and the P&F article explains more of the chemistry and science behind the technology.

At the end of the P&F article, the author writes that typical mass market prestige formulas are restricted to cost limits of around $20 per pound, and that this new biosynthesis technology could lower the cost of ingredients enough to allow better ingredients to be used in prestige scents, vastly improving their character. The author lists things like natural rose, jasmine, osmanthus, violet leaf, sandalwood, and vanilla that would be used if cost-effective versions existed. (I think she is envisioning reconstructions of the natural oils by putting together the appropriate biosynthesized natural isolate aroma chemicals that are found in the natural oils.)

I don’t know enough about this topic to make judgments yet, but I couldn’t help having a gut reaction to the lament about today’s poor mass market formulas. Artisan perfumers have been using expensive natural ingredients for years — we do use rose, jasmine, osmanthus and violet leaf absolutes, natural sandalwood oil, natural vanilla absolute, etc. We put the money into the juice rather than packaging, advertising, and celebrity endorsements. We operate on crazy budgets, doing as much as we can ourselves so that every possible dollar can go into the juice. Maybe the answer to the poor quality of mass market juice is not just to look for ways to lower the cost of ingredients but to also change the emphasis from the packaging and advertising to the juice. Artisan brands may put a larger dent into the market in the future because there are now so many of us. Each artisan can only make so many bottles, but together we create quite a lot. I suppose what we do is not significant compared to the quantity of mass market juice, but one can dream that together we are making a difference by offering more options.

biotechGMOnatural perfumeryperfume generalperfumery
9 comments
0
Facebook Twitter Google + Pinterest
Laurie

previous post
Checking in…
next post
Fragrance Event in Washington D.C. November 13

You may also like

Equestrian on Fragrantica Best of 2016

December 17, 2016

Oakmoss Q & A

February 11, 2010

Favorite Fall Scents and Happy Halloween!

November 1, 2008

The Skanky Notes

July 18, 2008

Friday Sniffing Notes

July 31, 2009

Talking fragrance design and more with Miriam Vareldzis...

November 11, 2013

Scent associations and a new book by a...

June 12, 2008

Interview with Dabney Rose: artisan perfumer, expert distiller...

December 9, 2013

More IFRA News

May 15, 2009

Update

January 16, 2012

9 comments

Jordan River October 29, 2013 - 4:35 am

Thank you for sharing your thoughts Laurie. I have no opinion at this stage.

Reply
Laurie E October 29, 2013 - 5:17 am

I’m not sure what to think either. I do think it’s sad that the motivation always seems to be to cut costs regardless of other considerations, and I hope there will be transparency.

Reply
Frankenspice | The Fragrant Man October 29, 2013 - 4:38 am

[…] Sonama Scent Studio – Laurie’s reaction […]

Reply
sasha October 29, 2013 - 3:31 pm

Thanks for this Laurie – not sure what to think just yet…

Reply
Laurie E October 29, 2013 - 5:04 pm

Yes, it will be interesting to see how it develops.

Reply
Tara October 29, 2013 - 4:20 pm

It sounds like a bad idea to me – I am against GMOs, and trying to lower the cost of ingredients by using them seems like the wrong approach. How about less money spent on packaging and advertising? That gets my vote.

Reply
Laurie E October 29, 2013 - 5:16 pm

That was my first reaction to the argument about improving quality of mass market scents — they have the power to improve quality now without these new ingredients if they’d adjust the way they spend the money. But I do see the argument about potentially being able to produce replacements for endangered natural ingredients like sandalwood. We already have new sustainably grown sandalwood plantations though (for example some successful efforts in Australia). I’m wary of GMO technology too, but at least the end product in this case is not GMO. It’s a complex issue!

Reply
Dionne October 29, 2013 - 5:21 pm

Hmmmm, I’m getting some red flags with this idea. And I admit, I’m cynical enough to believe that the big boys in perfumery (yeah, LVMH, I’m looking at you) will likely use this technology to increase the profit margin instead of increasing the quality. And the GMO thing concerns me a bit.

Reply
Laurie E October 29, 2013 - 5:23 pm

Yes.

Reply

Leave a Comment Cancel Reply

Search

SUBSCRIBE TO RECEIVE NEW POSTS VIA EMAIL




SUBSCRIBE TO RSS FEED

The Artisan Insider

Categories

  • Artisan Stories
  • Blog News
  • DIY
  • Favorites
  • In My Garden
  • Olfaction
  • Perfume
    • Featured Perfumery Posts
  • Personal
  • Personal Updates
  • Small Biz
  • Sonoma Finds: Art, Garden, & More
  • Sonoma Scent Studio Updates

Perfumery Highlights

  • The Fragrance Creation Process
  • Running An Artisan Perfume Business
  • Learning Perfumery: Classes & Schools
  • Ten Tips for Exploring the World of Perfume
  • Safety Standards For Natural Ingredients
  • Talking fragrance Design With Miriam Vareldzis
  • Interview with Dabney Rose: artisan perfumer, expert distiller and plantswoman
  • Defining Niche, Indie, and Artisan
  • Scent Concentration
  • A Brand’s Signature Base
  • Tincturing Ambergris

Olfaction Highlights

  • Study Finds 30% Difference in People’s Scent Receptors
  • More Discussion About Individual Scent Perception
  • Our Own Scent Truth
  • Every Human May Have A Unique Nose
  • More On Our Individual Sense Of Smell

Artisan Stories

  • Talking fragrance design and more with Miriam Vareldzis
  • Dabney Rose: artisan perfumer, expert distiller and plantswoman
  • Melissa Groben, perfumista & jewelry artist

Recent Posts

  • Sonoma Scent Studio Has A New Owner
  • Happy Easter/Passover!
  • How To File A USA Trademark For Less Than $300
  • Spring Visit to Garden at Ferrari-Carano Winery
  • Dreaming of Spring 2019

Recent Comments

  • Laurie on Learning Perfumery: Classes & Schools
  • Wendy Gardner on Learning Perfumery: Classes & Schools
  • Laurie on Learning Perfumery: Classes & Schools
  • Josefa on Learning Perfumery: Classes & Schools
  • Laurie on Learning Perfumery: Classes & Schools

Archives

Tags

allergens awards biotech botanical art chemical deer DIY employee EU restrictions Ferrari-Carano Winery garden gardens genetics gifts GMO Healdsburg how to IFRA infringement interview jewelry learning perfumery mandevilla vine mother's day mustard natural perfumery perfume general perfumery Preston Winery reviews roses Scent Perception skin care small business Sonoma sonoma scent studio spring TEAS TEAS Plus TESS trademark tulips USPTO winery wine tasting
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin
  • Email
Footer Logo

@2019 The Artisan Insider. All Rights Reserved. | Privacy Policy